[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]   [Date Index] [Thread Index] [Author Index

Re: "The Devil's Advocate," in BioTheory



Dear Judith,
 
Congradulations. It is a very interesting and excellent piece of work which subtly conveys the whole RR message in a nut shell. For those who have been part of the ongoing interactions within the list your article says a lot. I believe, it will also raise the curiosity of those who may be reading the E-journal as the first time and an urge to read the rest. My article,  representing RR's theory's application to other similar systems, now stands better between the real bio-applications of the theory and your science-fiction/non-fiction. E-journal still, however, needs to be fed with others with more living-systems oriented applications. Among these J.Kimmel's article will certainly be very supporting.  
 
Turning again to your article, I must say, it was a pleasant reading. I found the hell is a very liberal and comfortable place to be in, also ably administered by an intelligent, liberal, just and listening guard. Now being much more illuminated after the interview with Rosen, the same "Diavolo" may open the barrier between the Hell and the Paradise to be, so that both sides equally illuminated looking for more. Could that be the theme of your next work? By then with the work of others you may have more food for thought.
 
Recently I read a science fiction, with a great delight, of a well-known English Mathematician 'Ian Stewart' entitled "Flatterland" which is a kind of a sequel to Edwin.Abbott Abbott's masterwork "Flatland" written in late in 1900s, you may have read it already.The Ian's book finishes as its last chapter (18) headed 'The Tenth Dimension" with the following greatly suggestive short write-up as follows:
 
" Seen from space..... But it was a space. Well, a spacetime. Start again.
  Seen from a ten-dimensional supermanifold, it was a strange world, with the austere beauty of a page from Einstein. In fact, it was a page from Einstein, geometry made flesh. A sprawling, humming world of three dimensional shapes stacked together along one-dimensional time: women, men infants, toddlers, adolescents....People, of their own kind. They lived Peoplish lives, ate Peoplish food,  drank Peoplish drinks, made Peoplish love, bore Peoplish children, and died (Peoplishly) in a 3+1 dimensional universe, and never thought it the least bit curious. Their relativistic spacetime continuum was all they could see, all they could hear, all they could feel. To them, it was all there was.
  As long as nothing disturb that perception, it was true.
  But times (and spaces) were changing in Spacetimeland....."
 
Judith, if you have not read it I highly reccomend it to you to read, there you find an ally. In fact you start the reading from the chapter 17 'Flatterland', before you move to the 1st chapter.
 
My best,
Ayten
 
 
----- Original Message -----
To: ***
Sent: Wednesday, February 23, 2005 7:59 PM
Subject: "The Devil's Advocate," in BioTheory

Hi Folks,
 
I'm very pleased to announce that my personal written contribution to the science journal, BioTheory, that I launched last month... is now plugged into its spot at the journal. It is available for free in PDF format at the following link (Click on "Judith Rosen" when you get there...)
BioTheory: An E-Journal of General Science in the Rosennean Complexity Paradigm http://www.rosen-enterprises.com/RobertRosen/BioTheoryLaunch.htm
 
I suspect that this is not the type of paper many of you are used to finding in a science journal... just as well, really, for many reasons. (Heaven forbid that Rosens should be anything BUT UNorthodox...!) In any case... I tend to believe that this particular paper, about these particular subjects, will have far more truth, in a far more accessible mode, than it would be possible to craft as a writer, using the ordinary format of direct reportage. It's the only way I could really introduce anyone to my father, the man, as well as the science/scientist, at this juncture. The character in the fictional story, "The Devil's Advocate," whose name is Robert Rosen... is exactly faithful to the man I knew and so are his ideas, as far as is humanly possible. I think of fiction as the equivalent of a "word picture" and, as such, fiction can sometimes offer readers far more information than any sum of its words.
 
I would be interested in comments from the list, and constructive criticism is always welcome, too.
 
I hope it is of use to you.
 
Judith Rosen
Website address: http://www.rosen-enterprises.com/